A spore test is the only routine check that proves your autoclave actually killed microorganisms. The CDC recommends running one on every sterilizer at least once a week, and on every load that contains an implantable device.
A spore test, also called a biological indicator (BI), is a small vial or strip of highly heat-resistant bacterial spores (Geobacillus stearothermophilus for steam). You run it through a normal cycle, incubate it, and read the result. If those spores die, the less-resistant germs on your instruments died too. Chemical indicators and the sterilizer's printout show that conditions were reached; only the spore test shows the kill.
This guide covers how often to test, what the CDC and state boards expect, the three ways to test, a step-by-step walkthrough, and exactly what to do if a test fails.
When do you need to spore test?
At least once a week, on every sterilizer you use, plus every load with an implant. That is the CDC's guidance for dental settings, and it applies even if a sterilizer only runs part-time.
Routine: at least weekly per sterilizer, with a matching control vial from the same lot.
Every load with an implantable device. Ideally, hold the implant until the spore test comes back negative. This is where a 20-minute rapid readout matters most.
Extra tests the CDC lists on top of the weekly test:
- When you start using a new type of packaging material or tray
- After training new sterilization staff
- After the sterilizer is repaired
- After any change in how you load the sterilizer
Many manufacturers and infection control educators also recommend a spore test when a sterilizer is newly installed or relocated, and after any failed cycle. If you run more than one cycle type (for example, pouches and unwrapped), test each cycle you use.
Is spore testing required by law?
The CDC's weekly guideline is a recommendation, not a federal law, but most state dental boards have turned it into a rule or treat it as the standard of care. Boards inspect for spore test records and have disciplined dentists who skipped them. Always check your own state board and health department; frequency and record-retention rules vary.
| State / setting | What it requires | Source |
|---|---|---|
| California (dental) | Weekly biological indicator on every sterilizer; keep results 12 months | Delta Dental summary of CA regs |
| Ohio (dental) | Weekly biological monitoring of all sterilizers (OAC 4715-20-02); keep reports at least 2 years | Ohio State SMS |
| Oregon (dental) | Weekly monitoring since 2004; keep records for the current year plus the two prior years | Oregon Legislature analysis |
| Indiana (dental) | Weekly sterilizer testing | Indiana University SMS |
| Texas (dental) | Sterilizers tested per ADA recommendations (weekly) | Dentaltown |
| Massachusetts (dental) | Weekly spore testing on the state inspection form | MA inspection form |
| Wisconsin (tattoo/piercing) | Spore test at least monthly through an independent lab; keep records 1 year | Wis. Admin. Code SPS 221.14 |
Tattoo, piercing, salon, veterinary and medical offices are usually governed by the state or local health department, not a dental board, and many require monthly or lab-verified testing. Oregon's tattoo rules, for example, require written notice to clients after a positive spore test.
Three ways to spore test your autoclave
You can mail tests to a lab, or read them in your own office in about 10 hours or as fast as 20 minutes. All three meet the CDC guideline; the difference is how quickly you find out about a failure.
| Mail-in lab service | In-office, 10-hour | In-office, 20-minute rapid | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Time to result | Within 48 hours of the lab receiving it, plus mailing time | About 10 hours (color change) | 20 minutes (fluorescence auto-reader) |
| Paper result | Yes, issued by the lab | No; recorded in your logbook | Yes, printed when the read finishes |
| Equipment needed | None; kit includes mailers | Digital incubator | Auto-reader incubator |
| Starter kit includes | Biological indicators with culture service (12, 26 or 52 tests) | SteriCheck digital incubator, 100 10-hour BIs, Steripen chemical indicator pen, autoclave logbook | Bionova MiniBio Auto-Reader plus 50 20-minute BIs |
| If a test fails | Instruments from the days in transit may already be in use | You know within 5 to 10 hours (vial turns yellow) | You know before the load is used |
| FDA cleared | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Works for | Steam, EtO gas and dry heat | Steam | Steam |
| Best for | Low-volume offices that want third-party documentation | Offices that want same-day answers at low cost | Implant loads, busy practices, multi-location groups |
| Shop | SporeAlert mail-in kits | SteriCheck kits |
Bionova 20-minute BIs MiniBio Auto-Reader |
About the Bionova 20-minute indicator (BT224): each self-contained vial holds 106 Geobacillus stearothermophilus spores (ATCC 7953). The auto-reader detects fluorescence for a 20-minute result. The media stays purple after a successful cycle and turns green, then yellow, if spores survive. An optional visual color check after 48 hours adds a second confirmation. Shelf life is two years from manufacture.
The biggest practical difference is risk exposure. With mail-in testing, instruments sterilized while the test is in the mail are usually already back in use. If the result is positive, those loads are suspect. In-office testing closes that gap.
How to run an in-office spore test, step by step
The process takes a few minutes of hands-on time. Always follow the instructions for use (IFU) for your specific indicator and sterilizer; the steps below are the general sequence for a self-contained steam BI.
- Turn on the incubator or reader so it reaches temperature before you need it. Many take 20 minutes or more to warm up.
- Label the test vial with the date, sterilizer, cycle and load number. Set aside a second, unprocessed vial from the same lot as your control.
- Place the test vial in the hardest spot for steam to reach, usually inside a pouch or pack in the center of a normal, full load, as the BI and sterilizer IFUs direct.
- Run your normal cycle. Use the same cycle you use for patient instruments, not a special one.
- Let the vial cool before handling it. Some manufacturers specify at least 10 minutes.
- Activate both vials. Crush or close the cap to release the growth media, following the IFU. Activate the control the same way.
- Incubate test and control together. Place them in the reader or incubator side by side.
- Read the result. The control must show growth (it turns yellow or reads positive); that proves the spores were alive. The test vial should stay purple or read negative. Purple test plus yellow control is a pass.
- Record it. Log the date, sterilizer, cycle, load, BI lot number, test and control results, and who ran it.
What to do if your spore test fails
Take the sterilizer out of service and retest immediately with the same cycle. One positive result is often operator error, but you treat it as a failure until a repeat test proves otherwise.
- Stop using the sterilizer. Use a backup sterilizer or a loaner that has passed its own spore test.
- Recall implant loads. Any implantable items processed since the last negative test must be recalled and not used.
- Check the paperwork. Review the cycle printouts and chemical indicators for every load since the last negative test.
- Look for operator error. Check loading, packaging and cycle selection with everyone who runs the sterilizer.
- Retest right away with the same cycle that failed, loaded correctly.
- If the repeat test passes and procedures were correct, return the sterilizer to service.
- If the repeat test fails, keep the sterilizer out of service and call for inspection and repair. Before using it again, it must pass spore tests in three consecutive cycles. The CDC's 2003 dental guideline specifies empty-chamber cycles; follow your sterilizer manufacturer's IFU.
- Reprocess suspect loads. Recall, re-clean, re-wrap and re-sterilize items from loads dating back to the last negative test. CDC calls this the more conservative approach, and it is what most infection control experts recommend.
If the control vial did not grow, the test is invalid, not a pass. The spores may have been dead before the cycle. Repeat the test with a fresh pair from a good lot.
If you are a Duraline customer, call us at (877) 561-0500. Our manufacturer-certified technicians can diagnose the sterilizer, and rental sterilizers are available while it is repaired.
Why spore tests fail
Most failures trace back to how the sterilizer was loaded or packaged, not a broken machine. Common causes the CDC and educators list:
- Overloading or packs touching, so steam cannot circulate
- Wrong packaging for the sterilization method, or too much wrap
- Instruments not cleaned before sterilizing
- Wrong cycle selected, or a cycle interrupted or cut short
- Mishandled indicators: expired BIs, test and control mixed up, or a vial activated incorrectly
- Equipment problems: worn door gasket, clogged filters or air removal problems, heating faults
Regular preventive maintenance catches many equipment causes before they show up as a failed test.
Keeping spore test records
If it is not documented, inspectors treat it as not done. Keep every result for as long as your state requires; that ranges from 12 months (California) to the current year plus two (Oregon).
Each entry should include:
- Date and time of the test
- Sterilizer ID, cycle type and load number
- BI brand, lot number and expiration date
- Test result and control result
- Name of the person who ran and read it
- Any action taken after a failure
Also label each instrument package with the sterilizer, load number and date. If a test ever fails, that label is how you find the loads to recall.
Free video training when you buy from Duraline
Buy your spore tests or reader from Duraline and we will walk your team through spore testing on video, free. We show your staff how to place the indicator, run and activate it, read the result, log it, and respond to a failure, on your own sterilizer.
Need more than spore testing? We also offer full staff sterilizer training, virtually or in person. All Duraline technicians are certified by the manufacturers of the brands we sell.
- Shop biological indicators and readers and incubators
- Set up recurring delivery with AutoShip so you never miss a weekly test
- Call (877) 561-0500 or contact us to schedule your free training
Frequently asked questions
How often should I spore test my autoclave?
At least once a week per sterilizer, and every load that contains an implant. Your state may set additional rules.
Do I have to spore test if I only use my sterilizer part-time?
Yes. The CDC has no separate guideline for part-time sterilizers; weekly testing still applies.
Do I need to test a backup sterilizer?
If it is in use, yes. California's dental rules, for example, apply to every sterilizer in the sterilization area, including backups.
Can chemical indicators or strips replace a spore test?
No. Chemical indicators show conditions were reached, not that microorganisms were killed. The CDC states they do not replace weekly spore testing.
What does a positive spore test mean?
Spores survived the cycle, so sterilization may have failed. Take the sterilizer out of service and follow the steps above.
What does it mean if the control vial stays purple?
The test is invalid. The control must grow to prove the spores were alive. Repeat with a fresh pair.
How long does a spore test take?
Twenty minutes with a rapid reader, about 10 hours with a standard in-office incubator, or several days by mail once shipping is counted.
Where do I put the spore test in the autoclave?
In the hardest place for steam to reach in a normal load, usually inside a pack in the center. Follow your BI and sterilizer instructions.
Is mail-in or in-office spore testing better?
Both meet CDC guidance. Mail-in gives you third-party records with no equipment. In-office tells you about a failure the same day, before instruments reach patients.
Does Duraline offer training on how to spore test?
Yes. Customers who buy their spore tests or reader from Duraline get free video training for their team. Call (877) 561-0500 to schedule.
Sources
- CDC: Best Practices for Sterilization Monitoring in Dental Settings
- DentalCare CE 474: Procedures after a positive spore test
- Tuttnauer: Spore Testing Your Autoclave
- Dental Advisor: Requirements for sterilization monitoring
- Dimensions of Dental Hygiene: Spore tests and sterilizers
- Delta Dental: California QA spore test checklist
- Ohio State Sterilization Monitoring Service
- Oregon Legislature measure analysis, SB 1519
- Oregon tattoo sterilization rule OAR 331-915-0080

